Matthew 15:21-28

She Had Every Reason to Quit

Pastor Pat McFall, September 13, 2026, 37 min From the Matthew series

We measure faith by size and success, but Jesus measures it by trust and persistence. In Matthew 15:21-28, a Canaanite woman meets silence, a closed door and an insult, and keeps asking until Jesus says, “Woman, you have great faith!” Great faith keeps reaching when God seems silent and is too desperate to be offended.

Questions for your Life Group

Message notes

Pastor Pat opens with a question: how do you know if someone has great faith? We tend to measure it by big testimonies and big numbers. He points instead to people nobody has heard of: a youth pastor who took him surfing every week in freezing cold water, a mentor who told him, “Either God is enough for this moment or he just isn’t enough for me,” and his dad, who died of colon cancer when Pat was 12 and told him, “Whatever you do, it’s all about Jesus.”

Then he turns to Matthew 15. Jesus has just clashed with the Pharisees, and he goes to the region of Tyre and Sidon, the other side of the tracks. Matthew labels the woman who meets him a Canaanite on purpose, a name Jewish readers would have heard as a slur. She cries out, “Lord, Son of David, have mercy on me!” because her daughter is demon-possessed. Jesus says nothing. The disciples want her sent away. Jesus answers, “I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel.”

By every measure she is wrong: the wrong ethnicity, gender, religion and timing. Yet silence is not a no. Pat says “great faith keeps reaching” when God seems quiet, and he gives reasons God is sometimes silent. He may be testing whether we will chase him (Psalm 81). He may have already told us something we haven’t done. Often, Pat admits, he just stopped listening, or he didn’t like the outcome.

Next comes the hard line: “It is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to the dogs.” The word means a house pet under the table, and Pat doesn’t soften it. The woman doesn’t stop to be offended. “Even the dogs eat the crumbs.” Pat says “great faith is too desperate to be offended,” and asks what we are willing to be embarrassed for, from Costco returns to a good parking spot. Jesus answers, “Woman, you have great faith!” Matthew uses those words for only one other person, the Roman centurion.

Pat names the challenge of living somewhere people look so good that desperation feels risky. His main to-do: don’t stop asking. He urges young people to put Jesus first, because “priority increases your capacity,” and closes by inviting anyone desperate for Jesus to come forward and ask for help.

From the message

Big faith, we measure it by size or success, but Jesus measures it by trust and persistence.

Pastor Pat McFall Watch this moment, at (2:45)

Great faith keeps reaching. Even when God seems silent.

Pastor Pat McFall Watch this moment, at (7:20)

Great faith is too desperate to be offended.

Pastor Pat McFall Watch this moment, at (13:51)

It’s about a God who loves you enough to risk offending you in order to draw something out of you that he’s placed in you.

Pastor Pat McFall Watch this moment, at (28:56)

Life Group discussion guide

She Had Every Reason to Quit, Matthew 15:21-28. September 13, 2026.

Start here

What is something you have been willing to look a little embarrassing for, like cheering too loud at your kid’s event or holding a place in line?

Read Matthew 15:21-28

Open your Bibles and read it out loud together before you start.

What does it say?

  1. In Matthew 15:21-28, how does Jesus respond to the woman each time she asks, and how does she answer him each time?

  2. What do the disciples want Jesus to do in verse 23, and what reason do they give?

  3. What words does the woman use for Jesus in verses 22, 25 and 27, and what do they show about what she believed?

What does it mean?

  1. Pastor Pat pointed out that Matthew calls her a Canaanite on purpose. What would that label have meant to Jewish readers, and why would Matthew want them to hear this story?

  2. Matthew only uses the words “great faith” for two people, this woman and the Roman centurion in Matthew 8:10. What do those two outsiders have in common?

  3. Jesus’ first answers sound like a closed door. Why might he test her this way, and how could the same moment have been a test for the disciples?

What do we do with it?

  1. When God has seemed quiet in your life, which reason fits best: he wants you to chase him, he already told you something you haven’t done, or you stopped listening?

  2. Where do reputation, career or looking like you have it together keep you from being desperate before God, at work, at home or in your life group?

  3. What is one thing you asked God for once and then quietly stopped asking? What would it look like to keep asking this week?

Pray

Pray for the thing you gave up asking about. Ask Jesus for a faith that stays when he seems silent, the humility to not be offended when his answer bothers you, and the courage to ask others for help.

New Hope Hawaii Kai. Watch the message and read the notes at newhopehk.org/sermons/keep-asking-anyway/

Bring your questions on Sunday.

We meet at 9 AM in the Kaiser High School cafeteria. Kids from 6 months through 5th grade have their own class, so you can listen to the whole message.

See you Sunday.