Matthew 1:18-25
Unwavering Love
Love is not just sentimental, it’s sacrificial. On the fourth Sunday of Advent, Matthew 1:18-25 shows Joseph choosing mercy over his right to clear his name, then obeying God when it made him look foolish. Sacrificial love does the right thing when it costs, extends mercy when it is needed most and listens and obeys, pointing to Jesus, who loved us at the cost of the cross.
Message notes
On the fourth Sunday of Advent, Pastor Pat opens with 1 John 4:10: “This is love: not that we loved God, but that he loved us and sent his Son as an atoning sacrifice for our sins.” He talks Christmas movies, from The Muppet Christmas Carol to 8-Bit Christmas, where a boy spends the whole film chasing a Nintendo but remembers the treehouse his dad built. “Gifts that cost us something communicate something.” If we don’t dig deeper, Pat says, Christmas love stays stuck in nostalgia and feelings. Real love is a choice and a command, and it costs.
Then he turns to Joseph, who never gets a song and barely gets a line. Matthew says Joseph “was faithful to the law, and yet did not want to expose her to public disgrace,” so he planned to divorce Mary quietly. Pat explains betrothal: the couple was legally bound, and from the outside there were only two conclusions anyone in town could draw. Joseph had every right to defend himself. Instead he chose mercy.
An angel tells Joseph in a dream not to be afraid to take Mary home as his wife. Now he has to decide whether to apply the law the way he always has or trust God. Nobody had sinned, and yet obeying meant the town would think someone had. Pat admits he loves being right and being told he’s right, calling himself the mayor of Rightville. Joseph obeys and nobody ever hears his side of the story. Pat notes that some scholars think the stigma followed Jesus to Nazareth, though he says he can’t prove it.
Sacrificial love also listens and responds. Joseph gets up and marries Mary, then goes to Egypt, then returns to Israel, each time after a dream. Pat jokes that Joseph may have been afraid to fall asleep. His obedience opened the door for the promise that leads to the cross.
Pat brings it home. Sacrificial love lives at the dinner table and in staff meetings. It says, “I would rather be right with you than being right at all.” He warns that our culture disciples us toward disconnection, while noting that healthy boundaries are sometimes needed and should be discerned with Jesus and trusted people. He tells how his wife’s forgiveness and his own apologies to his kids after losing his temper have been some of the most beautiful moments in his family. Joseph didn’t get all the answers, just a next step, and Pat asks the church to take theirs.
From the message
Gifts that cost us something communicate something.
I would rather be right with you than being right at all.
Joseph didn’t get all the answers, but he got a next step.
If we settle for a version of love that doesn’t cost us anything, family, we will end up with a faith that never changes anything.
Life Group discussion guide
Unwavering Love, Matthew 1:18-25. December 21, 2025.
Start here
What is your favorite Christmas movie, and what gift from your childhood do you still remember?
Read Matthew 1:18-25
Open your Bibles and read it out loud together before you start.
What does it say?
In Matthew 1:19, how is Joseph described, and what did he plan to do about Mary?
What does the angel tell Joseph in verses 20-21, and what reason does he give for the child’s name?
What does Joseph do in verse 24, and how quickly does he do it?
What does it mean?
Pastor Pat said Joseph had every legal right to clear his name. Why might choosing a quiet divorce have been the most merciful option open to him?
1 John 4:10 says love is that God loved us and sent his Son as an atoning sacrifice. How does Joseph’s choice point ahead to the love Jesus showed on the cross?
Jesus said all the Law and the Prophets hang on loving God and loving our neighbor (Matthew 22:37-40). How does Joseph’s obedience show what keeping the law really looks like?
What do we do with it?
Where would you rather be right than be right with someone, at home, at work or in a friendship? What would choosing the relationship look like?
Is there an apology or a forgiveness conversation you have been avoiding this Christmas? What is your next step?
Where is God asking you to obey even though no one will applaud or even know?
Pray
Thank Jesus for a love that cost him everything. Ask him for the courage to take your next step of obedience and to extend mercy to the person you find hardest to forgive.
New Hope Hawaii Kai. Watch the message and read the notes at newhopehk.org/sermons/unwavering-love-advent2025/